Learning List Comprehensions

- 2 mins

#The Process of Learning What I Thought I Understood

I had an interesting experience the other day. I was working on an assignment that as part of the rules, did not allow me to use any kind of loop. We had gone over list and dictionary comprehensions and it seemed like a clear assignment to work on these elegant new structures. I thought I had them figured out! Really they didn’t seem too complicated, just a restructured version of a loop to fit on one line of code versus 3+ lines.

Ah, I was wrong. Close, but no cigar. My code still blew up all the same and it literally took me hours to figure out a single line of code. Otherwise I had finished the assignment. Let me show you the loop and the comprehension I was trying to replace it with.


  for arg in args
    if len(arg) != length:
      raise ShapeException


  [raise ShapeException for arg in args if len(arg) != length]

The loop works! If the length of this arg does not equal the length I want it to be, it raises an exception. Imagine my distress when the comprehension that I thought would be interchangeable, doesn’t actually work!

The reason it doesn’t work, the reason that took me far more time than I care to admit, is that a comprehension != a restructured loop. Programmers better than I was at the time of my distress will realize the error easily. The first part of a comprehension is a ‘collection’ and I was essentially trying to do a call to action to raise an exception error. The code I ended up actually using looks like this:


valid_args = [arg for arg in args if len(arg) == length]
    if len(valid_args) != len(args):
        raise ShapeException

In this piece of code, I’m working with a comprehension in a more correct way. This first step is adding the arg in the sequence of args to a string called valid_args, it’s ‘collecting’ it. Then I can do a simple if statement and raise the same exception if the lengths of all the args and the valid_args doesn’t match.

It was a very frustrating way to learn how comprehensions actually work, but I have to say, I think I get it now.

Andrew Pierce

Andrew Pierce

Software Engineer based in Durham, NC

comments powered by Disqus
rss facebook twitter github youtube mail spotify instagram linkedin google google-plus pinterest medium vimeo stackoverflow reddit quora